Skip to content
Scoop and Swap

TroubleshooterA few questions, then the likely cause and what to change

Sourdough Starter Troubleshooter: No Bubbles, Hooch, Smell or Mold

Describe what you see in the jar and get a plain answer from extension sources: what is normal, how to revive a sleepy starter and when to discard it.

By Paul Gunder

Updated

Checked against saved USDA, FDA or extension pages2 sources, listed belowHow we check
Photograph of a jar of bubbly sourdough starter with a band marking its level beside flour
On this page

Sourdough starter troubleshooter: no bubbles, hooch, smell or mold

Describe what you see in the jar. The tool separates harmless oddities, such as a liquid layer, from the one sign that means the starter goes in the trash: mold.

What are you seeing in the jar?

Fuzzy or colored spots, or clumps on the surface

What do the spots look like?

Look at the surface with good light. Do not smell it up close.

Fuzzy, or any color of spot

Act now

Throw it out: any mold means the starter cannot be used

Colorado State Extension is clear: a starter that shows any sign of mold, colored or fuzzy, should not be used. Mold means the culture was contaminated, and you cannot save it by scooping the spots off. If you cannot tell whether what you see is mold, treat it as mold.

What to do

  1. Do not taste it, and do not use it to bake. Throw the whole starter out.
  2. Wash and rinse the container thoroughly before you start over.
  3. Start a new starter, or revive a dried backup if you saved one.
  4. Keep the new starter loosely covered, which discourages mold while letting gas escape.
Whitish clumps floating on the liquid layer of a starter kept in the refrigerator

Keep an eye on it

Safe yeast clumps, not mold: feed the starter and carry on

Colorado State says a starter kept in the refrigerator and not fed regularly can grow whitish clumps on the surface of the liquid layer. These are safe yeasts, not mold. They usually show a starter that has gone without feeding.

What to do

  1. Pour off or stir in the liquid, then remove some of the starter and feed it fresh flour and water.
  2. Feed on a regular schedule, or keep it cold and feed it before baking.
  3. If the clumps ever look fuzzy or colored, throw the starter out instead.
I cannot tell

Act now

Throw it out: any mold means the starter cannot be used

Colorado State Extension is clear: a starter that shows any sign of mold, colored or fuzzy, should not be used. Mold means the culture was contaminated, and you cannot save it by scooping the spots off. If you cannot tell whether what you see is mold, treat it as mold.

What to do

  1. Do not taste it, and do not use it to bake. Throw the whole starter out.
  2. Wash and rinse the container thoroughly before you start over.
  3. Start a new starter, or revive a dried backup if you saved one.
  4. Keep the new starter loosely covered, which discourages mold while letting gas escape.
Little or no bubbling, rising or doubling

How has the starter been kept?

It is new, or I just rehydrated a dried starter

Keep an eye on it

A young starter: give it several days of regular feeding

Colorado State says creating a starter or rehydrating a dried one takes several days of regular feeding. It will bubble and rise, and develop a pleasantly sour smell when it is ready. Wild yeast on the flour is inactive until water wakes it up.

What to do

  1. Feed on schedule with fresh flour and water, and remove some starter at each feeding.
  2. Keep it somewhere that feels comfortable to you, around 70°F.
  3. Keep it loosely covered, and do not taste it.
  4. Write down each feeding so you can judge progress.
It sits somewhere cold or very hot

Keep an eye on it

Temperature is slowing it down, or pushing it too fast

Colorado State says starter organisms do best at a warm room temperature, around 70°F. Fermentation slows in the cold and can run too rapidly or even stop when it is too hot. Refrigeration prolongs the time between feedings, so a starter kept cold will seem asleep.

What to do

  1. Move the jar to a spot that feels comfortable to you, not near a heater or in a cold corner.
  2. If it came from the refrigerator, feed it at room temperature a few times before baking with it.
  3. Keep it loosely covered while it ferments.
I feed it only now and then

Keep an eye on it

Irregular feeding starves the culture

Colorado State says the microorganisms in a starter need to be fed fresh flour and water regularly to survive and grow, and that removing some starter at each feeding stabilizes the volume and gives the culture nourishment. Regularly spaced feedings are needed.

What to do

  1. Pick a feeding schedule you can keep, and remove some starter at each feeding.
  2. If you cannot feed often, keep the starter in the refrigerator, which prolongs the gap.
  3. Dry some starter for long-term storage as a backup.
It was bubbly before and has gone flat or sleepy

Keep an eye on it

A starter that went flat: check the room, the schedule and the last feeding

Colorado State lists time, temperature, moisture, acidity, nutrients and oxygen as the factors that shape a starter. A culture that once bubbled and now lies flat has usually lost one of them: the room turned cold or hot, feedings drifted apart, or it spent time in the refrigerator. Regular feeding with fresh flour and water, with some starter removed each time, brings it back over several days.

What to do

  1. Move the jar somewhere that feels comfortable to you, around 70°F, and away from drafts and heaters.
  2. Remove some starter, feed it fresh flour and water, and repeat at regular intervals rather than once.
  3. Keep it loosely covered so gas can escape. The culture does not need oxygen.
  4. Judge readiness by bubbles, a tangy smell, a batter-like texture and expansion, and write down each feeding.
I changed flours, or I am not sure the flour suits it

Keep an eye on it

Flour type changes how a starter develops

Colorado State says flour type has an impact on the microbial development of a starter and on the final product. Neither source names a best flour, so treat a change of flour as one variable and keep the rest of your routine steady while you watch what happens.

What to do

  1. Change one thing at a time: the flour, or the schedule, or the temperature, not all at once.
  2. Keep feeding at regular intervals and remove some starter each time.
  3. Note the flour and the date in your feeding record so you can compare the results.
  4. If it stays flat after several days of regular feeding, go back to the flour that worked.
A layer of liquid on top

Keep an eye on it

A liquid layer that smells of alcohol is normal

Colorado State says a starter may develop a liquid layer that smells of alcohol, and that this is fine. The liquid is a by-product of the fermenting yeast and can either be poured off or stirred in.

What to do

  1. Pour the liquid off or stir it in, then feed the starter.
  2. Feed on a regular schedule so the starter stays active.
  3. Check the surface for fuzzy or colored spots. If you see any, throw the starter out.
A smell I am not sure about

How does it smell?

Pleasantly sour or tangy

Keep an eye on it

A pleasantly sour smell is a healthy sign

Colorado State says to judge a starter by a bubbly appearance, a tangy smell, a batter-like consistency, expansion and your records of when you fed it. A pleasantly sour smell develops as the starter becomes ready to use.

What to do

  1. Keep feeding it fresh flour and water regularly, and remove some each time you feed.
  2. Do not taste raw starter. Use the look, smell and rise to tell when it is ready.
  3. Bake the bread fully, since baking kills any bacteria present.
Like alcohol, with liquid on top

Keep an eye on it

A liquid layer that smells of alcohol is normal

Colorado State says a starter may develop a liquid layer that smells of alcohol, and that this is fine. The liquid is a by-product of the fermenting yeast and can either be poured off or stirred in.

What to do

  1. Pour the liquid off or stir it in, then feed the starter.
  2. Feed on a regular schedule so the starter stays active.
  3. Check the surface for fuzzy or colored spots. If you see any, throw the starter out.
Flat or floury, with no tang yet

How has the starter been kept?

It is new, or I just rehydrated a dried starter

Keep an eye on it

A young starter: give it several days of regular feeding

Colorado State says creating a starter or rehydrating a dried one takes several days of regular feeding. It will bubble and rise, and develop a pleasantly sour smell when it is ready. Wild yeast on the flour is inactive until water wakes it up.

What to do

  1. Feed on schedule with fresh flour and water, and remove some starter at each feeding.
  2. Keep it somewhere that feels comfortable to you, around 70°F.
  3. Keep it loosely covered, and do not taste it.
  4. Write down each feeding so you can judge progress.
It sits somewhere cold or very hot

Keep an eye on it

Temperature is slowing it down, or pushing it too fast

Colorado State says starter organisms do best at a warm room temperature, around 70°F. Fermentation slows in the cold and can run too rapidly or even stop when it is too hot. Refrigeration prolongs the time between feedings, so a starter kept cold will seem asleep.

What to do

  1. Move the jar to a spot that feels comfortable to you, not near a heater or in a cold corner.
  2. If it came from the refrigerator, feed it at room temperature a few times before baking with it.
  3. Keep it loosely covered while it ferments.
I feed it only now and then

Keep an eye on it

Irregular feeding starves the culture

Colorado State says the microorganisms in a starter need to be fed fresh flour and water regularly to survive and grow, and that removing some starter at each feeding stabilizes the volume and gives the culture nourishment. Regularly spaced feedings are needed.

What to do

  1. Pick a feeding schedule you can keep, and remove some starter at each feeding.
  2. If you cannot feed often, keep the starter in the refrigerator, which prolongs the gap.
  3. Dry some starter for long-term storage as a backup.
It was bubbly before and has gone flat or sleepy

Keep an eye on it

A starter that went flat: check the room, the schedule and the last feeding

Colorado State lists time, temperature, moisture, acidity, nutrients and oxygen as the factors that shape a starter. A culture that once bubbled and now lies flat has usually lost one of them: the room turned cold or hot, feedings drifted apart, or it spent time in the refrigerator. Regular feeding with fresh flour and water, with some starter removed each time, brings it back over several days.

What to do

  1. Move the jar somewhere that feels comfortable to you, around 70°F, and away from drafts and heaters.
  2. Remove some starter, feed it fresh flour and water, and repeat at regular intervals rather than once.
  3. Keep it loosely covered so gas can escape. The culture does not need oxygen.
  4. Judge readiness by bubbles, a tangy smell, a batter-like texture and expansion, and write down each feeding.
I changed flours, or I am not sure the flour suits it

Keep an eye on it

Flour type changes how a starter develops

Colorado State says flour type has an impact on the microbial development of a starter and on the final product. Neither source names a best flour, so treat a change of flour as one variable and keep the rest of your routine steady while you watch what happens.

What to do

  1. Change one thing at a time: the flour, or the schedule, or the temperature, not all at once.
  2. Keep feeding at regular intervals and remove some starter each time.
  3. Note the flour and the date in your feeding record so you can compare the results.
  4. If it stays flat after several days of regular feeding, go back to the flour that worked.
Something else that seems wrong

What do the spots look like?

Look at the surface with good light. Do not smell it up close.

Fuzzy, or any color of spot

Act now

Throw it out: any mold means the starter cannot be used

Colorado State Extension is clear: a starter that shows any sign of mold, colored or fuzzy, should not be used. Mold means the culture was contaminated, and you cannot save it by scooping the spots off. If you cannot tell whether what you see is mold, treat it as mold.

What to do

  1. Do not taste it, and do not use it to bake. Throw the whole starter out.
  2. Wash and rinse the container thoroughly before you start over.
  3. Start a new starter, or revive a dried backup if you saved one.
  4. Keep the new starter loosely covered, which discourages mold while letting gas escape.
Whitish clumps floating on the liquid layer of a starter kept in the refrigerator

Keep an eye on it

Safe yeast clumps, not mold: feed the starter and carry on

Colorado State says a starter kept in the refrigerator and not fed regularly can grow whitish clumps on the surface of the liquid layer. These are safe yeasts, not mold. They usually show a starter that has gone without feeding.

What to do

  1. Pour off or stir in the liquid, then remove some of the starter and feed it fresh flour and water.
  2. Feed on a regular schedule, or keep it cold and feed it before baking.
  3. If the clumps ever look fuzzy or colored, throw the starter out instead.
I cannot tell

Act now

Throw it out: any mold means the starter cannot be used

Colorado State Extension is clear: a starter that shows any sign of mold, colored or fuzzy, should not be used. Mold means the culture was contaminated, and you cannot save it by scooping the spots off. If you cannot tell whether what you see is mold, treat it as mold.

What to do

  1. Do not taste it, and do not use it to bake. Throw the whole starter out.
  2. Wash and rinse the container thoroughly before you start over.
  3. Start a new starter, or revive a dried backup if you saved one.
  4. Keep the new starter loosely covered, which discourages mold while letting gas escape.
It looks active, but my bread did not turn out

Keep an eye on it

The starter is fine, so look at the loaf

A bubbly, tangy, expanding starter is doing its job. If the bread still came out dense, flat or collapsed, the cause is probably in the dough, the rise or the oven. Colorado State also notes that low humidity and low pressure at altitude change how baking behaves, so use recipes adjusted for altitude.

What to do

  1. Walk through the bread troubleshooter with the way the loaf turned out.
  2. At altitude, follow a recipe adjusted for altitude or use Colorado State's high-altitude guidance.
  3. Keep records of your feeding and baking steps so you can see what changed.

What this tool does

A sourdough starter is a jar of living yeast and bacteria, and it can look alarming when it is perfectly fine. A layer of liquid, a sharp smell or a sleepy surface sends many bakers to the trash when nothing is wrong, while a real sign of trouble can be missed. This troubleshooter separates harmless quirks from real trouble. You describe what you see, answer a follow-up question, and it tells you whether to feed, wait, adjust or discard.

The guidance comes from Colorado State University Extension and a University of California youth project guide that reprints it. Both treat the starter as an ecosystem you manage by controlling time, temperature, moisture, acidity, nutrients and oxygen.

What is normal and what is not

A liquid layer that smells of alcohol is fine. It is a by-product of the fermenting yeast, and you can pour it off or stir it in. A starter kept in the refrigerator and fed only now and then may grow whitish clumps on that liquid. Those are safe yeasts, not mold. A pleasantly sour, tangy smell, a bubbly look and a batter-like texture are signs of a healthy starter, and you should judge readiness by them rather than by tasting raw starter.

Mold is the exception. Colored or fuzzy growth means the starter is contaminated and must be discarded. The acidity of a healthy ferment helps limit harmful growth, and keeping the jar loosely covered discourages mold while letting gas out.

Why a starter stalls

A new or newly rehydrated starter needs several days of regular feeding before it bubbles and rises. Temperature matters: the organisms do well at a comfortable room temperature, around 70°F, slow down in the cold, and can run too fast or even stop when it is too hot. Irregular feeding starves the culture, which needs fresh flour and water at regular intervals, with some starter removed each time. Refrigeration can stretch the time between feedings, but a cold starter often needs a few warm feedings to wake up.

Why is my sourdough starter not rising?

A starter that will not rise, bubble or double is almost always short of time, warmth or regular food. The extension sources do not give a single cause, so work through the list in the order a baker can check it fastest.

How old is it? Making a starter from scratch, or waking a dried one, takes several days of regular feeding before it bubbles and rises. A jar that looks flat on its second morning is on schedule, not failing. The wild yeast that arrives on the flour sits inactive until water reaches it.

How warm is the room? The microorganisms work best at a temperature that feels comfortable to you, around 70°F. A cold kitchen slows fermentation, so a jar on a cool windowsill can look dead while it is only slow. Too much heat has the opposite effect: fermentation can run too fast or stop entirely.

Is the feeding regular? The culture needs fresh flour and water at evenly spaced intervals, and the sources stress removing some starter each time. Skipping that step leaves a crowded jar that runs out of nutrients. A starter fed only now and then, or taken straight from the refrigerator, often needs a few warm feedings before it bubbles again. Refrigeration only stretches the gap between feedings; it does not replace them.

Has the flour changed? Colorado State notes that flour type affects how the culture develops. Neither source ranks flours, so change only one thing at a time and keep notes.

A starter that is not bubbling or has not doubled is not the same as a starter that is spoiled. Judge by the look, the tangy smell, the batter-like texture and any expansion. Only fuzzy or colored growth means discard.

How to use the tool

Choose what you see. The mold path asks you to look closely at the surface, and it sends anything fuzzy, colored or uncertain to the trash. The stall path asks how the starter has been kept, including whether it was bubbly once and went flat, or whether the flour changed. If your starter looks active but the bread is poor, the last result points you to the bread troubleshooter.

Worked example

A baker pulls a jar from the back of the refrigerator after a long trip. There is a gray-ish liquid on top and a few pale clumps floating in it, and the smell is sharp. She picks "Fuzzy or colored spots, or clumps on the surface," then "Whitish clumps floating on the liquid layer of a starter kept in the refrigerator." The result says these are safe yeast clumps, not mold, and she pours off the liquid, removes some starter, and feeds it. After a few warm feedings it bubbles again. Had the spots been fuzzy or colored, the answer would have been to discard it.

Common questions

Why is my sourdough starter not bubbling?

Check its age, its temperature and its feeding first. A new or rehydrated starter needs several days of regular feeding, a cold room slows the bubbles, and a starter fed only occasionally loses activity. Keep it near a comfortable room temperature, feed it on a steady schedule and wait.

Why is my starter not doubling after I feed it?

Doubling depends on a healthy, well-fed culture at a workable temperature. Remove some starter before each feeding, use fresh flour and water, and keep the jar out of the cold. Expansion is one of several signs of readiness, along with bubbles, a tangy smell and a batter-like texture.

Why did my starter go flat after feeding?

A flat jar after feeding usually means the conditions changed: a cooler room, a longer gap between feedings or a stay in the refrigerator. Return it to a comfortable room, feed it regularly for several days and note each feeding. If a liquid layer appears, it is a harmless by-product you can pour off or stir in.

Does the kind of flour matter?

It can. Colorado State says flour type has an impact on the starter's microbial development and on the final product. The sources do not name a best flour, so keep the flour the same while you troubleshoot, and change it only as a deliberate experiment.

Is a starter that will not rise safe to bake with?

Not rising does not make it unsafe, but it also will not leaven bread well. The safety signal is mold, meaning any colored or fuzzy growth, and that always means throwing the starter away. Do not taste raw starter to check on it.

When to start over

Start over whenever mold appears or you cannot tell what you are seeing. For help with moldy food in general, see the moldy food troubleshooter and the mold on food chart.

Sources

  1. Colorado State University Extension, Sourdough starter best practices extension.colostate.edu
  2. University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources, Sourdough (4-H project guide) oc4h.ucanr.edu