Skip to content
Scoop and Swap

LookupA searchable reference table

Ingredient Substitution Finder: What Can I Use Instead?

A searchable table of ingredient swaps for baking and cooking. Type what you are out of, read the amount, and see what the swap does to texture, color and flavor.

By Paul Gunder

Updated

Checked against saved USDA, FDA or extension pages12 sources, listed belowHow we check
Overhead photograph of unlabelled glass jars of baking staples on a wooden pantry shelf
On this page
Ingredient substitutions, each backed by at least two university extension or government sources
IngredientAmountSwapBest forWhat changes
Baking powder (double-acting)1 teaspoon¼ teaspoon baking soda plus 5/8 teaspoon cream of tartarAny recipe that uses baking powder as its leavenerSame gas-making chemistry: the cream of tartar is the acid that lets the soda release carbon dioxide
Baking powder (double-acting)1 teaspoon¼ teaspoon baking soda plus ½ cup sour milk or buttermilk, and ½ cup less of the other liquidBatters with at least ½ cup of liquid you can trade outAdds the tang of soured milk; its acid does the job of the cream of tartar
Baking powder (double-acting)1 teaspoon¼ teaspoon baking soda plus ¼ to ½ cup molassesRecipes where a molasses flavor is welcomeAdds molasses color and flavor; molasses is acidic enough to react with the soda
Cream of tartar½ teaspoon½ to 1½ teaspoons lemon juice or vinegarA recipe or a homemade baking powder that needs an acidAdds a little liquid and flavor; the acid is what counts. Sources differ on the amount
Self-rising flour1 cup1 cup minus 2 teaspoons all-purpose flour plus 1½ teaspoons baking powder and ½ teaspoon saltBiscuits and other recipes that call for self-rising flourYou add the leavening and salt the flour would have carried; mix them in well
Buttermilk (or sour milk)1 cup1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar plus enough milk to make 1 cup; let stand 5 to 10 minutesPancakes, biscuits and quick breads, and any recipe using baking sodaThinner and milder than cultured buttermilk, but acidic enough to react with baking soda. Sources differ on standing time
Buttermilk (or sour milk)1 cup1 cup milk plus 1¾ teaspoons cream of tartarBaking when you have cream of tartar but no lemon juice or vinegarSupplies the acid for baking soda without adding extra liquid
Buttermilk1 cup1 cup plain yogurtPancakes, muffins and other batters that use baking sodaAcidic like buttermilk, so it still works with baking soda
Heavy cream1 cup¾ cup milk plus ⅓ cup butter or margarineCooking and baking onlyWill not whip into a topping
Whipped creamAny amountChill a 13-ounce can of evaporated milk for 12 hours, add 1 teaspoon lemon juice, then whip until stiffA whipped topping when there is no creamNeeds the full 12 hours of chilling before it will whip
Half-and-half1 cup1 cup evaporated milk, undilutedCooking and bakingUsed straight from the can, not thinned with water
Sour cream1 cup1 cup plain yogurtDips, sauces and toppingsYogurt separates when heated. NDSU adds 1 tablespoon cornstarch per cup in cooking; UMaine says to avoid it in cooked dishes
Sour cream1 cup¾ to ⅞ cup sour milk plus ⅓ cup butterBaking, where the butter replaces the richnessThinner than sour cream, so it suits batters better than dips. Sources differ on the amount of milk
Mayonnaise (salads and dressings)1 cup1 cup sour cream, plain yogurt or cottage cheese puréed in a blenderSalads, salad dressings and dipsUse any of them for part of the mayonnaise, not necessarily all of it
Plain yogurt1 cup1 cup buttermilk, sour cream or cottage cheese blended until smoothRecipes that call for yogurt and you have another cultured dairyCottage cheese needs blending until smooth to pass for yogurt
Whole milk1 cup½ cup evaporated milk plus ½ cup waterCooking and bakingSlightly different flavor and richness than fresh milk
Cornstarch (for thickening)1 tablespoon2 tablespoons all-purpose flourSauces, gravies and fillings that are cookedFlour is the weaker thickener, so you use twice the amount
Cornstarch (for thickening)1 tablespoon2 tablespoons granular tapiocaCooked sauces and fillingsNeeds to cook with the liquid until the granules soften and thicken
All-purpose flour (for thickening)1 tablespoon½ tablespoon cornstarch, potato starch, rice starch or arrowroot starchWhen a recipe calls for flour as the thickener and you want a starch insteadNeeds only half as much as flour (1½ teaspoons per tablespoon)
Brown sugar (firmly packed)1 cup1 cup granulated sugarRecipes where brown sugar is a small part of the flavorLoses the molasses flavor, color and moisture; brown sugar is also mildly acidic, which matters with baking soda
Brown sugar (firmly packed)1 cup1 cup granulated sugar plus ¼ cup molassesClosest match to the real thing, in cookies, bars and cakesRestores the molasses color, moisture and flavor that make brown sugar brown
Granulated (white) sugar1 cup1 cup brown sugar, firmly packedBakes where a deeper color and flavor are welcomeDarker and moister, with a molasses taste
Granulated (white) sugar1 cup¾ to 1 cup honey, with ¼ cup less liquid; in baked goods add ½ teaspoon baking soda per cup of honeyCakes, cookies and quick breads, replacing part of the sugarMoister and sweeter; honey is acidic, so it needs the soda. Sources differ on the amount
Sugar (to cut back)1 cup⅔ to ¾ cup sugarMost baked goods and desserts, but not yeast breadsCookies spread less and brown paler; quick breads brown less and can dry out. Sources differ on how far to cut
Corn syrup1 cup1 cup sugar plus ¼ cup of the recipe's liquidRecipes that need a syrup but you only have sugarThe added liquid makes up for the syrup's water
Honey1 cup1¼ cups sugar plus ¼ cup liquidBaking when the jar is emptyLoses honey's flavor and moisture
Molasses1 cup¾ cup sugar plus 1¼ teaspoons cream of tartar, and 5 tablespoons more liquidRecipes with a small amount of molassesLoses molasses flavor and color; the cream of tartar replaces its acid
Powdered (confectioners') sugar1 cup1 cup granulated sugar plus 1 teaspoon to 1 tablespoon cornstarch, blended until powderyFrostings and dustings when the box is emptyNeeds a food processor or blender; sources differ on the cornstarch
Butter1 cup1 cup regular (stick) margarineBaking and cooking when the margarine is not low-fat or tub-styleClose to butter, but low-fat and tub spreads hold more water and give a poorer result
Butter1 cup⅞ to 1 cup shortening, plus ½ teaspoon salt where the sources add itCookies you want to spread lessNo butter flavor, and cookies stay softer than ones made with butter. Sources differ on the amount
Butter1 cup⅞ cup lard plus ½ teaspoon saltSavory bakes where butter flavor is optionalNo butter flavor
Butter (melted)1 cup⅞ to 1 cup oil, only when the recipe uses melted butterRecipes that call for melted butterSofter, chewier, denser or flatter results, and not flaky. Sources differ on the amount
Shortening, melted1 cup1 cup cooking oil, only if the recipe calls for melted shorteningRecipes that already melt the shorteningOil does not trap air the way a solid fat does
Shortening, solid1 cup1⅛ cups butter or margarine, and ½ teaspoon less saltBaking when you are out of shorteningButter and margarine hold a little water, so the extra amount makes up for it
Butter, margarine, oil or shortening (in baking)Up to half the fatReplace half the fat with applesauce or another fruit pureeCutting fat in baked goodsMoister result; baking time may be 25% shorter, and applesauce adds moisture, so consider less liquid elsewhere
Butter, margarine, oil or shorteningAny amountUse up to ⅓ less fatGravies, sauces, puddings and quick breadsLess tender: muffins and biscuits with reduced fat are often tougher
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup mashed ripe bananaMoist cakes, muffins and pancakesGives a definite banana flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup unsweetened applesauceCakes, muffins and quick breadsA sweeter, chewier, denser result with a slight fruit flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ to ½ cup plain yogurt (dairy or non-dairy)Muffins and cakesAdds moisture. Sources differ on the amount
Egg (large)Per egg3 tablespoons peanut or other nut butterBrownies, cookies and dense baked goodsSlight nut flavor, and an obvious allergy concern
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup mashed avocadoChocolate bakesAdds moisture and its own flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup pumpkin or sweet potato puree, mashed beans or silken tofuMoist cakes and brownies where you need moisture, not liftAdds moisture but no leavening, and may add flavor
Egg (large)Per egg1 tablespoon ground flaxseed or chia plus 3 tablespoons water; let sit 5 to 10 minutesBinding in breads, cookies and pancakesDenser result; chia adds texture and a little crunch. Sources differ on the wait
Egg (large)Per egg1 to 2 teaspoons baking powder plus 1½ to 2 tablespoons water plus 1 to 1½ tablespoons oilLight, fluffy cakes, and pancakes or quick breads that need liftLeavens but does not bind, and tends to bake denser. Sources differ on the amounts
Egg (large)Per egg3 tablespoons aquafaba (chickpea liquid), whippedMeringues, brownies and cookiesCookies spread a little more and bake crunchier
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup unflavored carbonated waterLight-textured baked goodsLeavens but does not bind
Egg (large)Per egg2 tablespoons mayonnaiseCakesAdds moisture; flavor and texture may shift slightly
Egg (large)Per egg½ teaspoon baking powder plus 1 tablespoon vinegar plus 1 tablespoon liquidBaking onlyAdds lift, not richness or binding
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup commercial egg substitute (follow the package)General baking; the label has the directionsMade to behave like egg, but check the label, since some contain egg
Egg (large)Per egg2 egg whitesGeneral baking when you want less fatLeaves out the yolk's fat; still egg, so not for an egg allergy
Egg (large)Per egg3 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon thawed frozen eggAny recipe that calls for whole eggStill egg, so not for an egg allergy
Cake flour1 cup sifted1 cup minus 2 tablespoons sifted all-purpose flourCakes and other recipes that call for cake flourTexture may differ a little from the original
All-purpose flour1 cup sifted1 cup plus 2 tablespoons cake flourWhen you have cake flour but no all-purposeTexture may differ a little from the original
All-purpose (white) flourAny amountWhole wheat flour for ¼ to ½ of the white flourAdding fiber without changing the whole recipeHeavier and denser, and a smaller loaf in yeast bread
Allspice1 teaspoon½ teaspoon cinnamon plus ½ teaspoon ground clovesBaking and spice blendsClose, not identical, in flavor
Apple pie spice1 teaspoon½ teaspoon cinnamon, ¼ teaspoon nutmeg and 1/8 teaspoon cardamomApple desserts and bakingClose, not identical, in flavor
Pumpkin pie spice1 teaspoon½ teaspoon cinnamon, ¼ teaspoon ginger, 1/8 teaspoon allspice and 1/8 teaspoon nutmegMuffins, pies and quick breadsClose, not identical, in flavor
Unsweetened chocolate1 ounce (1 square)3 tablespoons cocoa plus 1 tablespoon butter, margarine or oilBrownies, cakes and other chocolate bakingThe added fat stands in for the cocoa butter in the chocolate
Cocoa¼ cup (4 tablespoons)1 ounce (square) unsweetened chocolate, with ½ tablespoon less fat in the recipeChocolate bakingThe chocolate already carries fat, so the recipe's fat comes down
Fresh garlic1 small clove1/8 teaspoon garlic powderCooked dishes, sauces and rubsClose, not identical, in flavor
Fresh herbs (finely cut)1 tablespoon1 teaspoon dried leaf herbsCooked dishes, dips and dressingsDried herbs are stronger by volume, so the amount drops
Fresh herbs (finely cut)1 tablespoon½ teaspoon ground dried herbsCooked dishesGround herbs are stronger still than dried leaves
Fresh onion1 small, or ¼ cup chopped1 to 2 tablespoons instant minced onionCooked dishes such as meatloaf and soupsDrier, with a different flavor than fresh onion. Sources differ on the amount
Fresh onion1 small, or ¼ cup chopped1 to 1½ teaspoons onion powderCooked dishes such as meatloaf and soupsDrier, with a different flavor than fresh onion. Sources differ on the amount
Lemon juice1 teaspoon½ teaspoon vinegarRecipes where the acid matters more than the lemon flavorLoses the lemon taste
Lemon zest or peel1 teaspoon½ teaspoon lemon extractCakes, cookies and glazesExtract is stronger than zest, so the amount halves
Dry mustard1 teaspoon1 tablespoon prepared mustardCooked mixturesPrepared mustard is wetter and milder than the dry powder, so you use more
Ketchup (for cooking)1 cup1 cup tomato sauce, ½ cup sugar and 2 tablespoons vinegarCooked sauces and glazesThe sugar and vinegar supply the sweet-tart taste
Barbecue sauce1 cup¾ cup ketchup, 2 tablespoons mustard and 2 tablespoons brown sugarBasting and glazesBuilt from pantry condiments, so the flavor is simpler
Tomato juice1 cup½ cup tomato sauce plus ½ cup waterSoups and stewsThe water thins the sauce to the body of juice
Tomato soup10¾-ounce can1 cup tomato sauce plus ¼ cup waterCasseroles and saucesA plain tomato base, so season it yourself
Bread crumbs¼ cup1 slice of breadMeatballs, meatloaf and toppingsFresh bread gives soft crumbs, not dry ones
Miniature marshmallows1 cup10 large marshmallowsTreats and toppingsLarge marshmallows stand in for the small ones piece for piece

What this finder does

You are halfway through a recipe and the buttermilk, the cornstarch or the last egg is missing. Type the ingredient into the search box above and the table narrows to every swap we have for it. Each row gives the amount of the original, the swap and how much of it to use, the kind of recipe it suits best, and what to expect once the substitute is in the bowl.

The table covers baking staples such as eggs, leavening, flour, sugar and fats, dairy such as buttermilk, cream and sour cream, thickeners, spices and herbs, and a few pantry sauces. If the ingredient you want is missing, it means we could not find the same ratio in more than one saved source, and we would rather leave a gap than guess.

How we choose what goes in the table

Home-baking forums and recipe blogs are full of swap charts that copy each other. We did not use any of them. Every row here comes from university extension publications and government pages that we saved and read: Texas A&M, Utah State, Kansas State, North Dakota State, Nebraska, Illinois, Wisconsin, North Carolina, Mississippi State and Maine. A swap only makes the table when more than one of those sources gives the same ratio, and every number on a row appears in the quoted text of those sources. A swap that only one source mentions is left out, or mentioned in the guide in words with no amount.

Extension sources do not always agree. Where they differ, the row shows the range and says that sources differ, rather than quietly choosing one. A good example is cream of tartar standing in for acid: one publication gives a small amount of lemon juice or vinegar and another gives a larger one, so the row shows both ends. Start at the low end, taste the batter if it is safe to do so, and adjust the next time.

Reading a row

The "Best for" column says where the swap tends to work. The "What changes" column is the honest part: it names the flavor, texture or rise you give up. Moisture, fat, acid and structure are the main jobs most ingredients do in a recipe, and the changes column is usually about one of them. If a swap trades a dry ingredient for a wet one, expect a different batter thickness. If it trades an acid for a plain ingredient, expect less rise from baking soda.

Worked example: pancakes without buttermilk

The recipe wants a cup of buttermilk and the carton is empty. Search "buttermilk" in the finder. The first swap is 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar with enough regular milk to make a full cup, left to stand. Sources give 5 minutes and, in one case, 5 to 10 minutes, so the row shows the range. The soured milk is thinner than cultured buttermilk but acidic enough to react with the baking soda, so the pancakes still rise. If you have plain yogurt instead, the table lists that too. The buttermilk guide goes through each option in more detail.

Where to go next

The detailed guides cover the swaps people search for most: egg substitutes for baking, baking soda and baking powder, buttermilk, cornstarch and butter. If a bake still goes wrong after a swap, the cake troubleshooter, the cookie troubleshooter and the bread troubleshooter help you work out which ingredient to blame.

Food safety rules still apply to swapped ingredients. Check how long an opened carton keeps with how long does food last before you reach for dairy that has been in the refrigerator a while.

Sources

  1. Utah State University Extension, List of ingredient substitutions for cooking and baking extension.usu.edu
  2. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension, Basic ingredient substitutions food.unl.edu
  3. University of Illinois Extension, Recipe substitutions extension.illinois.edu
  4. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, Quick ingredient substitutions agrilifeextension.tamu.edu
  5. North Dakota State University Extension, Ingredient substitutions (FN198) ndsu.edu
  6. Kansas State University Research and Extension, Ingredient substitutions (L730) bookstore.ksre.ksu.edu
  7. NDSU Extension, Prairie Fare: What ingredient swaps work in recipes? ag.ndsu.edu
  8. University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Altering recipes for better health (Bulletin 4167) extension.umaine.edu
  9. Mississippi State University Extension, How to use ingredient substitutes to lower sugar and fat extension.msstate.edu
  10. University of Illinois Extension, Functions of fats in the kitchen extension.illinois.edu
  11. University of Wisconsin–Madison Extension Dane County, Egg substitutes for baking dane.extension.wisc.edu
  12. N.C. Cooperative Extension, Baking with egg substitutes brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu