Skip to content
Scoop and Swap

LookupA searchable reference table

Butter Substitute for Baking: Margarine, Shortening, Lard and Oil

Butter swaps for baking by recipe, plus what fat does to tenderness and spread. Includes margarine, shortening, lard, melted oil, applesauce and cutting fat.

By Paul Gunder

Updated

Checked against saved USDA, FDA or extension pages8 sources, listed belowHow we check
Photograph of butter, a cruet of oil and a dish of shortening on a floured counter with muffins behind
On this page
Butter and other fat swaps for baking
IngredientAmountSwapBest forWhat changes
Butter1 cup1 cup regular (stick) margarineBaking and cooking when the margarine is not low-fat or tub-styleClose to butter, but low-fat and tub spreads hold more water and give a poorer result
Butter1 cup⅞ to 1 cup shortening, plus ½ teaspoon salt where the sources add itCookies you want to spread lessNo butter flavor, and cookies stay softer than ones made with butter. Sources differ on the amount
Butter1 cup⅞ cup lard plus ½ teaspoon saltSavory bakes where butter flavor is optionalNo butter flavor
Butter (melted)1 cup⅞ to 1 cup oil, only when the recipe uses melted butterRecipes that call for melted butterSofter, chewier, denser or flatter results, and not flaky. Sources differ on the amount
Shortening, melted1 cup1 cup cooking oil, only if the recipe calls for melted shorteningRecipes that already melt the shorteningOil does not trap air the way a solid fat does
Shortening, solid1 cup1⅛ cups butter or margarine, and ½ teaspoon less saltBaking when you are out of shorteningButter and margarine hold a little water, so the extra amount makes up for it
Butter, margarine, oil or shortening (in baking)Up to half the fatReplace half the fat with applesauce or another fruit pureeCutting fat in baked goodsMoister result; baking time may be 25% shorter, and applesauce adds moisture, so consider less liquid elsewhere
Butter, margarine, oil or shorteningAny amountUse up to ⅓ less fatGravies, sauces, puddings and quick breadsLess tender: muffins and biscuits with reduced fat are often tougher

What fat does in a bake

Fat does several jobs at once. It makes baked goods tender by keeping flour from soaking up water and forming too much gluten, which is why muffins and biscuits made with less fat turn out tougher. It carries flavor. When you cream butter or shortening with sugar, it traps tiny air pockets that help the bake rise. In yeast breads, fat helps the gluten stretch and gives a larger loaf. And its melting point decides how far cookies spread.

Butter is 80% fat with 20% water, and that water matters. Regular margarine is similar, and margarine with at least 55% oil is the kind that bakes best. Shortening is all fat. Oil is liquid fat. Each behaves differently, which is why the swap you choose should depend on the recipe.

Swaps by recipe

Cookies. Butter and margarine give thinner, crisper cookies because they melt at a lower temperature than shortening and carry a little water. Shortening makes cookies spread less and stay softer, with no butter flavor. If your cookies are spreading too much, a shortening swap is one fix. For the amount, the sources give a range of 7/8 to 1 cup per cup, and some add salt.

Cakes and quick breads. Regular stick margarine can replace butter cup for cup. If a recipe uses melted butter, such as many muffins, brownies and quick breads, oil can take its place. Sources differ on whether the amount is equal or slightly less, so the table gives a range. Oil traps little air, so expect a softer, chewier, denser result.

Pastry and pie crust. This is where a swap shows most. Solid fats make pastry flaky, and replacing them with oil makes it mealy rather than flaky. Keep to a solid fat: lard and shortening are both listed as butter swaps, and the table gives the lard amount along with the salt it needs.

Cutting fat. Fat can often be reduced by up to 1/3 in many recipes, especially quick breads, puddings and sauces. Or replace half the fat with applesauce or another fruit puree. Baking time may drop by 25%, and you may need to reduce other liquid. Bananas add a strong flavor that suits chocolate bakes but not sugar cookies.

What to expect

A swap for butter trades flavor for structure or the other way around. Margarine is closest. Shortening and lard give no butter flavor. Oil changes the crumb. Fruit puree makes things moister and denser. If you plan to repeat a recipe, change one thing at a time.

Worked example: chocolate chip cookies

The dough calls for a cup of butter and you have a block of shortening and a stick of margarine. Use margarine cup for cup to stay closest to the original. If you use shortening, the sources suggest slightly less than a cup plus a little salt. Either way, bake one test pan first. Shortening cookies will be taller and softer, while margarine cookies resemble the original. If they spread into thin crisps, the cookie troubleshooter helps you adjust.

If you are trading oil for butter in a cake, the cake troubleshooter explains what a dense crumb means. For melted-fat and liquid-ingredient swaps, see the ingredient substitution finder. Butter and margarine keep differently in the refrigerator, so check how long does food last for opened packages.

Sources

  1. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, Quick ingredient substitutions agrilifeextension.tamu.edu
  2. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension, Basic ingredient substitutions food.unl.edu
  3. Utah State University Extension, List of ingredient substitutions for cooking and baking extension.usu.edu
  4. Kansas State University Research and Extension, Ingredient substitutions (L730) bookstore.ksre.ksu.edu
  5. University of Illinois Extension, Functions of fats in the kitchen extension.illinois.edu
  6. North Dakota State University Extension, Ingredient substitutions (FN198) ndsu.edu
  7. University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Altering recipes for better health (Bulletin 4167) extension.umaine.edu
  8. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension, Fats in baking (G2187) extensionpubs.unl.edu