Skip to content
Scoop and Swap

LookupA searchable reference table

Sour Cream Substitute: Yogurt, Soured Milk and Butter

Swaps for sour cream and for the dairy that stands in for mayonnaise and yogurt. The page says when yogurt is safe to heat and when it will separate.

By Paul Gunder

Updated

Checked against saved USDA, FDA or extension pages8 sources, listed belowHow we check
Photograph of a bowl of thick yogurt beside a baked potato topped with yogurt and chives
On this page
Sour cream and related dairy swaps
IngredientAmountSwapBest forWhat changes
Sour cream1 cup1 cup plain yogurtDips, sauces and toppingsYogurt separates when heated. NDSU adds 1 tablespoon cornstarch per cup in cooking; UMaine says to avoid it in cooked dishes
Sour cream1 cup¾ to ⅞ cup sour milk plus ⅓ cup butterBaking, where the butter replaces the richnessThinner than sour cream, so it suits batters better than dips. Sources differ on the amount of milk
Mayonnaise (salads and dressings)1 cup1 cup sour cream, plain yogurt or cottage cheese puréed in a blenderSalads, salad dressings and dipsUse any of them for part of the mayonnaise, not necessarily all of it
Plain yogurt1 cup1 cup buttermilk, sour cream or cottage cheese blended until smoothRecipes that call for yogurt and you have another cultured dairyCottage cheese needs blending until smooth to pass for yogurt

What sour cream does

Sour cream brings fat, tang and thick body. In dips and toppings, it provides richness and a cool sourness. In baking it adds moisture and acid, and extension baking guidance lists sour cream among the acidic ingredients that react with baking soda to make a bake rise. A replacement should be thick, acidic and, ideally, fatty.

Plain yogurt, the easy swap

The sources agree on 1 cup plain yogurt as a stand-in for sour cream at equal volume. It works well in cold dishes, such as dips, dressings and toppings, and in baked goods. Greek yogurt is thicker and creamier and makes an especially good dip. One extension nutrition column suggests starting by replacing only part of the sour cream with Greek yogurt, since it does not have to be all or nothing.

The weak point is heat. One publication warns that yogurt is not heat stable and says to avoid it in cooked dishes. Another allows it in cooking if you add a tablespoon of cornstarch to each cup. The sources do not agree, so be cautious: for a stroganoff or a hot dip, stir the yogurt in after the pan has come off the heat, or use the cornstarch method.

Soured milk and butter

When there is no yogurt, soured milk and butter reproduces the fat and acid. The sources differ on the amount of milk, so the table gives a range, with butter supplying the richness. This mixture is thinner than sour cream, so it suits batters, cakes and muffins better than dips or toppings.

The reverse swaps

Sour cream is also the swap for other things. It stands in for mayonnaise in salads and dressings, sometimes blended with yogurt or puréed cottage cheese, and the sources say to use it for part of the mayonnaise rather than all. And when a recipe asks for plain yogurt, the table lists buttermilk, sour cream and smooth-blended cottage cheese as stand-ins.

Lower-fat choices

Reduced-fat and fat-free sour cream exist, and plain fat-free yogurt can replace full-fat sour cream in cold sauces and dips. Fat contributes to a tender, moist crumb in baking, so full-fat versions are the safer bet when the sour cream is a main ingredient in a cake.

Worked example: coffee cake without sour cream

A coffee cake recipe asks for a cup of sour cream. Plain yogurt, measured cup for cup, is the quickest answer. The crumb will be slightly tangier and a bit less rich. If you want it richer, you could use the soured milk and butter row, which brings back fat. In either case, mix the batter gently so the cake stays tender.

Next steps

Dairy that works in one recipe is not always right in another. If your cake comes out dense, the cake troubleshooter can help you find why. For storage times on open tubs, see how long does food last, and for other dairy swaps see the heavy cream guide.

Sources

  1. Utah State University Extension, List of ingredient substitutions for cooking and baking extension.usu.edu
  2. North Dakota State University Extension, Ingredient substitutions (FN198) ndsu.edu
  3. University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Altering recipes for better health (Bulletin 4167) extension.umaine.edu
  4. Kansas State University Research and Extension, Ingredient substitutions (L730) bookstore.ksre.ksu.edu
  5. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension, Basic ingredient substitutions food.unl.edu
  6. University of Illinois Extension, Recipe substitutions extension.illinois.edu
  7. Mississippi State University Extension, How to use ingredient substitutes to lower sugar and fat extension.msstate.edu
  8. NDSU Extension, Prairie Fare: Add to the levity of baking with these tips ag.ndsu.edu