Skip to content
Scoop and Swap

LookupA searchable reference table

Egg Substitute for Baking: What Works in Brownies, Cakes and Cookies

Pick the recipe type, find the egg swap that suits it, and see the amount per egg. Every amount is backed by more than one extension source, and the page notes where egg-free is not the same as allergen-free.

By Paul Gunder

Updated

Checked against saved USDA, FDA or extension pages9 sources, listed belowHow we check
Photograph of brownie batter beside small dishes of mashed banana, flaxseed gel and applesauce
On this page
Egg substitutes for baking, per large egg
IngredientAmountSwapBest forWhat changes
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup mashed ripe bananaMoist cakes, muffins and pancakesGives a definite banana flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup unsweetened applesauceCakes, muffins and quick breadsA sweeter, chewier, denser result with a slight fruit flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ to ½ cup plain yogurt (dairy or non-dairy)Muffins and cakesAdds moisture. Sources differ on the amount
Egg (large)Per egg3 tablespoons peanut or other nut butterBrownies, cookies and dense baked goodsSlight nut flavor, and an obvious allergy concern
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup mashed avocadoChocolate bakesAdds moisture and its own flavor
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup pumpkin or sweet potato puree, mashed beans or silken tofuMoist cakes and brownies where you need moisture, not liftAdds moisture but no leavening, and may add flavor
Egg (large)Per egg1 tablespoon ground flaxseed or chia plus 3 tablespoons water; let sit 5 to 10 minutesBinding in breads, cookies and pancakesDenser result; chia adds texture and a little crunch. Sources differ on the wait
Egg (large)Per egg1 to 2 teaspoons baking powder plus 1½ to 2 tablespoons water plus 1 to 1½ tablespoons oilLight, fluffy cakes, and pancakes or quick breads that need liftLeavens but does not bind, and tends to bake denser. Sources differ on the amounts
Egg (large)Per egg3 tablespoons aquafaba (chickpea liquid), whippedMeringues, brownies and cookiesCookies spread a little more and bake crunchier
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup unflavored carbonated waterLight-textured baked goodsLeavens but does not bind
Egg (large)Per egg2 tablespoons mayonnaiseCakesAdds moisture; flavor and texture may shift slightly
Egg (large)Per egg½ teaspoon baking powder plus 1 tablespoon vinegar plus 1 tablespoon liquidBaking onlyAdds lift, not richness or binding
Egg (large)Per egg¼ cup commercial egg substitute (follow the package)General baking; the label has the directionsMade to behave like egg, but check the label, since some contain egg
Egg (large)Per egg2 egg whitesGeneral baking when you want less fatLeaves out the yolk's fat; still egg, so not for an egg allergy

What an egg does in a recipe

Before you pick a swap, work out what the egg is doing. Extension specialists describe three jobs: it binds the batter so it holds together, it adds moisture, and it helps the bake rise. A single recipe may lean on the egg for one of those more than the others, and the right replacement depends on which one. A fruit puree replaces moisture and some binding but adds no lift. A mixture of baking powder, oil and water adds lift but does not bind. Neither one is an all-purpose egg.

One large egg is roughly ¼ cup of liquid, so most swaps below are sized to fill that space. The table lists every swap with the amount per egg.

Matching the swap to the recipe

Brownies. Brownies are dense and chocolatey, so they tolerate heavy, moist swaps. Nut butter at 3 tablespoons per egg is listed for brownies and other dense bakes, and whipped aquafaba, the liquid from canned chickpeas, is listed for brownies too, at Three tablespoons per egg. Mashed avocado is noted as working well with chocolate, though it brings its own flavor. Fruit purees such as banana or applesauce also work, though the brownies come out chewier and denser.

Cake. Cakes need moisture and lift. For a moist cake, mashed banana, applesauce or yogurt are the usual picks. For a light, fluffy cake, baking powder mixed with water and oil is the swap one source recommends, and mayonnaise is listed as suitable for cake batter. Where the egg is mostly the leavening, extension volunteers suggest a commercial egg replacer instead. Pound cake, sponge cake and angel food cake depend on whole eggs for their structure and do not turn out well with swaps.

Cookies. Ground flax or chia gel, applesauce and aquafaba all worked in a cookie test run by a county extension office, and the flax and applesauce cookies were judged best. The aquafaba cookies spread more and baked crunchier.

Muffins and quick breads. Banana, applesauce and yogurt suit muffins and quick breads, because those bakes want moisture. If the batter needs more lift, flax, chia or the baking powder mixture give some, though they tend to bake denser.

Breads and pancakes. Chia or ground flax gel is the swap listed for breads, cookies and pancakes. Wait five minutes or longer for the gel to thicken before you stir it in.

Limits to know about

Egg swaps usually do not work when a recipe calls for more than 3 eggs, because the eggs are then the structure of the bake. Sources also disagree on a few amounts, such as yogurt and the baking powder mixture, and the table shows the range when they do.

Egg-free still needs to be cooked through

Skipping the egg removes the main worry with raw batter, but flour can carry bacteria too. Bake eggless goods to an internal temperature of at least 165 degrees Fahrenheit, and avoid eating raw dough. Our egg storage and safety guide covers the eggs you do use.

Worked example: a pan of brownies

Say a brownie recipe calls for a pair of eggs and the carton is empty. Because brownies are dense, nut butter is a sound choice if no one has a nut allergy, at 3 tablespoons for each egg. If someone does, use ¼ cup mashed avocado per egg, or whip aquafaba until foamy. Expect a denser pan than the original. Nothing here is a perfect match, so make the swap in a recipe you can afford to test.

If it goes wrong

A flat cake, a gummy center or cookies that spread are all signs the swap did a different job than the egg did. The cake troubleshooter and the cookie troubleshooter walk through the symptoms. For other swaps, return to the ingredient substitution finder.

Sources

  1. University of Wisconsin–Madison Extension Dane County, Egg substitutes for baking dane.extension.wisc.edu
  2. N.C. Cooperative Extension, Baking with egg substitutes brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu
  3. University of Illinois Extension, Recipe substitutions extension.illinois.edu
  4. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, Quick ingredient substitutions agrilifeextension.tamu.edu
  5. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension, Basic ingredient substitutions food.unl.edu
  6. Mississippi State University Extension, How to use ingredient substitutes to lower sugar and fat extension.msstate.edu
  7. University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Altering recipes for better health (Bulletin 4167) extension.umaine.edu
  8. USDA FSIS, Egg Products and Food Safety fsis.usda.gov
  9. U.S. FDA, Food allergies (major food allergens) fda.gov